The aftermath of Gerry Turner and Theresa Nist’s whirlwind romance and subsequent split from the reality show The Golden Bachelor has taken a chilling turn. Theresa Nist recently alleged that Turner made a disturbing “joke” about killing her during their brief relationship, raising serious concerns among fans.
In an interview on the Dear Shandy podcast, Nist described a walk they took around Pretty Lake. She recounted how Turner pointed to a nearby shed and said, “That’s where I’m going to hide your body after I kill you and chop you up.” She emphasized that he was not laughing and stated she felt an underlying animosity in his tone. While Nist clarified that she doesn’t believe Turner would have actually harmed her, the statement nonetheless deeply troubled her.
Nist’s account has sent shockwaves through the Golden Bachelor fandom. Comments on social media highlight the gravity of such a remark, with many stressing that threats of violence should never be dismissed as jokes. Some fans pointedly questioned why Nist didn’t heed these warning signs sooner.
Turner has not yet publicly responded to Nist’s allegations. This silence adds another layer to an already tangled narrative.
The pair met during filming for the first season of The Golden Bachelor in late 2023. Their whirlwind romance culminated in a televised wedding ceremony on January 4th, 2024. However, the marriage proved short-lived; Turner filed for divorce three months later, citing “irreconcilable differences.”
Adding fuel to the fire, Turner recently announced the release of his memoir, Golden Years, claiming he was portrayed as a villain by Nist. He further hinted that the book would reveal information making Nist “worried.”
The unfolding story underscores the complexities and potential dangers lurking beneath the surface of reality television’s curated narratives. The allegations against Turner raise serious questions about the dynamics within their relationship, adding a disturbing new dimension to an already tumultuous public saga.
