25 Easy Christmas Cookie Recipes for Holiday Baking

19

The holiday season is synonymous with sweet treats, and few things capture the spirit quite like freshly baked Christmas cookies. Whether you’re planning a festive gathering, assembling a gift tin, or simply enjoying a cozy afternoon, these 25 easy recipes offer something for every baker. From classic gingerbread to surprising tahini creations, this collection covers a wide range of flavors and techniques, ensuring a joyful baking experience for all skill levels.

Traditional Christmas Favorites

Many holiday baking traditions center around familiar flavors. Gingerbread cookies, with their warm spice and decorative potential, remain the most popular choice, boasting over 300 five-star reviews. Buttery Mexican Wedding Cookies (or snowballs) melt in your mouth, while classic Christmas Sugar Cookies provide a perfect canvas for colorful icing and sprinkles. For a different twist, try Thumbprint Cookies filled with apricot or raspberry jam, or Chewy Molasses Cookies, ready in just 30 minutes.

These recipes tap into nostalgia and the comfort of well-loved flavors.

Spritz Cookies excel in both taste and longevity, keeping well for weeks and freezing beautifully – ideal for gifting. Pignoli Cookies, featuring a pine nut crust, offer an elegant Italian touch, while Peanut Butter Blossoms topped with Hershey’s Kisses remain a crowd-pleaser.

Shortbread & Sugar Cookie Variations

Shortbread and sugar cookies provide versatile foundations for experimentation. Simple Shortbread Cookies require only five ingredients, while Easy Sugar Cookies can be rolled in colored sugar for extra festivity. Lemon Cookies add a zesty twist, and Orange Shortbread Cookies brighten the spread with citrus flavor. For an unexpected herbal note, try Lemon Shortbread Cookies with fresh thyme.

The key here is simplicity: minimal ingredients, maximum flavor.

Chocolate Lover’s Delights

Even during the holidays, chocolate cravings don’t disappear. Chocolate Chip Cookies, though not strictly traditional, are always welcome on any cookie plate. For a deeper indulgence, try Double Chocolate Chip Cookies (some bakers even add peppermint extract). Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookies prove that deliciousness doesn’t require butter or eggs. Cranberry Cookies introduce festive red and green colors with dried cranberries and pistachios.

Soft, Spiced & Nutty Options

Soft textures and warm spices dominate this category. Snickerdoodles, perfected with an extra egg yolk, offer a chewy cinnamon-sugar experience. Perfect Oatmeal Cookies can be enhanced with dried cherries and white chocolate chips for a holiday twist. Soft Pumpkin Cookies are cake-like and pair wonderfully with cream cheese frosting. Best Peanut Butter Cookies, packed with peanut butter, satisfy the salty-sweet craving, while No-Bake Cookies provide a dense, fudgy alternative when oven space is limited. Almond Butter Cookies offer a nutty twist on the classic peanut butter formula.

Creative & Unexpected Cookies

For bakers seeking something different, these recipes push boundaries. Tahini Cookies topped with pomegranate arils offer a gluten-free option with rich, nutty flavor and warm spices. Finally, Matcha Cookies introduce a vibrant green hue and delicate earthy notes.

Ultimately, the best Christmas cookie is the one that brings joy to those who bake and enjoy it. Whether you stick to tradition or experiment with new flavors, the act of baking together creates lasting memories.