The Ultimate Almond Milk Taste Test: Finding the Creamiest, Nuttiest, and Sweetest Brands

23

Almond milk has evolved from a niche dietary option to a mainstream staple, but its history stretches back centuries. Originating in ninth-century Islamic texts, it spread to Europe as a dairy alternative long before modern health trends took hold. Today, with countless brands vying for shelf space, discerning the best almond milk requires careful evaluation. We put 11 popular brands to the test, focusing on creaminess, flavor balance, and overall drinkability.

The Quest for the Perfect Almond Milk

The ideal almond milk should mimic dairy in texture and functionality – thick, subtly sweet, and free from grittiness. It needs to perform well in coffee, cereal, and even baking without falling flat. While some brands emphasize “clean” labels, others prioritize creamy indulgence. Our blind taste test sought to identify which brands delivered the best experience across these criteria.

The Winners Emerge

After rigorous evaluation, three almond milks stood out:

  • Good & Gather Unsweetened Original Almond Milk (Target): This option earned the top spot for its remarkably dairy-like texture. Testers noted its thickness and versatility, making it ideal for coffee or straight from the glass. It strikes a balance between drinkability and richness, avoiding the thinness of many competitors.
  • MALK Organic Unsweetened Almond Milk: The most authentic almond flavor of the group, MALK’s nuttiness divided tasters. Some appreciated its purity, while others found it slightly stale. Despite mixed reactions, its creamy body and bold almond taste make it a standout choice for those seeking a true almond experience.
  • Nature’s Promise Plant-Based Original Almond Milk (Stop & Shop, Hannaford, Giant Food): This brand’s sweetness makes it a strong contender as a coffee creamer alternative. While some testers found the sugar content excessive, those accustomed to sweetened dairy creamers may appreciate its familiar flavor profile.

What Sets These Brands Apart?

The Good & Gather almond milk’s superior texture comes down to ingredients: gellan gum, xanthan gum, and sunflower lecithin create a dairy-fat-like richness. In contrast, MALK’s minimal ingredient list (filtered water, organic almonds, Himalayan pink salt) delivers a more authentic but less stable flavor. Nature’s Promise relies on cane sugar for sweetness, which some found overpowering.

Methodology and Impartiality

To ensure unbiased results, all taste tests were conducted blind. Testers sampled brands in random order, without discussion, ranking them based on pre-defined criteria. Data was tabulated objectively, with no editorial influence to ensure an accurate representation of actual preferences.

Ultimately, Good & Gather emerges as the most versatile option, but MALK and Nature’s Promise each offer unique strengths depending on individual taste and use cases. The best almond milk isn’t a single answer; it’s the one that best suits your needs.